Last week I played soccer for the first time in years. The
goalkeeper kicked the ball high (probably about 20 metres into the air)
and a teammate called to me to head it.
I realise I am lacking in
skill, but the power of the ball striking my head knocked me off my
feet, bruised my forehead and left me with a dreadful headache. Yet
professional footballers seem able to head higher and faster-moving
balls with no apparent damage or pain.
What velocities and forces are
they dealing with, and why did the ball leave me stunned but not a
professional player?
When you head a soccer/football, you must hit it with more force than the ball has - transferring your energy to the ball rather than your own head. This is the same as with headbutting someone in the head. The aim is to make the energy hit the back of their head. This, combined with the angle and the part of the head you use allows you to head a soccer/football with minimal damage.
Perhaps a physicist could elaborate.
As true as it seems with footballers and their thick skulls, it is not a necessity :P
The dissyness is caused by your brain hitting the front of your skull when your head rocks back on being hit by the ball. This is also the cause of damage during boxing. To reduce it, it is important to keep your head as steady as possible and that means practice and building up strong muscles.
Local bruising is different, this will be worse if you do not go with the blow, but the pain is less depending on the area of your head that gets hit. If you think of your head as a cube, the front corners are usually less painful to hit and if the ball scuffs you (slides over the top or side of your head) this might tear some skin, remove some hair and of course hurt.
I have some reservations about how practice and strength can make this activity any safer for anyone. The ball's momentum is changed and that is undisputed. Likewise the player's momentum is changed equally and in the opposite direction. The brain suffers.
The most effective player usually gives the ball the biggest momentum change and so his brain suffers most.
The strong neck's purpose is to share some of the new momentum with the lower parts of the body. I agree that the strong neck of a good player is effective. His good timing ensures that his neck is braced at the right time to accept the blow and transfer maximum momentum to the body. Then again, does this mean that the blow is softer for the head? I don't think so. It seems that the blow is more severe because the good player returns the ball with more speed and accuracy. It certainly wasn't just a glancing blow or a dribbled return.
the answer is simple techinque.....
look at professional footballers and you will see that they rarely ever just headbutt a ball( unless they are diving into it etc), usually what happens is that they momentarily cock their heads backwards at the moment of impact ( thus lessening the impulse of the blow) before bashing the ball in the prefered direction, they also tend to use the flattest part of the skull because , well its easier to bounce sumn of a flat surface... also another thing to consider is that during heated matches with the adreniline rush and enorphin surge , pain becomes a dull concept , only the action of the moment matters
The effect is related to other athletic feats like breaking wooden planks with a karate chop. Elements of the body are linked in what is called in biomechanics a 'kinetic chain' - the athlete increases the effective mass of the head in the collision by stiffening the neck muscles to This has two useful effect. First, it adds some fraction of the body mass to the effective mass of the head in the head/ball collision - this causes the ball to bounce back fast in the desired direction instead of stopping dead (as happens when two similar-mass objects collide, like snooker balls). Second, the stiff neck prevents the skull from snapping backwards and hitting the brain which is floating inside of it.
Imagine you were able to head a stationary ball to the goalkeeper
from where you were standing that day. The force your head would have to
exert on the ball would be equal in magnitude to the force exerted by
the keeper kicking the ball. Since the ball exerts an equal reaction
force on your head, it would be as if the keeper had kicked you in the
head. Consider yourself lucky to just end up with a bruise or a
headache.
In practice you would, of course, not be trying to head
the ball all the way back to the keeper, but there are other things to
consider with a falling ball. Ignoring air resistance, a football
dropping vertically from 20 metres would hit the ground at a speed of
nearly 20 metres per second. If you could reverse the velocity of the
ball by heading it, assuming the ball has a mass of 400 grams and is in
contact with your head for one-hundredth of a second, the force you
experience is around 1500 newtons - the weight of two adults.
When professional footballers head the ball, they
generally apply a small force to deflect it, usually to steer it into
the net. That does not require taking the full force of the ball on the
head. But if that is the only option, they use their necks, backs and
knees as shock absorbers. In so doing, they increase the time the ball
takes to slow down. By Newton's second law - force equals mass times
acceleration, or in this case deceleration - this reduces the ball's
deceleration and thus the force. However, as you have found, it takes
skill and experience to get the timing right.