Advanced search

Answers


How can glass be see-through?

I know that a solid is solid because the atoms are packed closely together, but if this is true, then how can we see through solid substances such as glass if there is no space between the atoms?

 

sssss
 (no votes)

submit an answer
  • Asked by Lauren
  • on 2009-08-08 16:47:14
  • Member status
  • none

Categories: Our universe.

Tags: Glass, atoms, trasnparant.

 

Report abuse


7 answer(s)


Reply

suzysunshine1985 says:

Glass is actually a very slow moving liquid (according to my physics teacher in A levels many years ago) and that is why the glass in very old buildings looks bumpy.. If you look through the windows in a really old cathedral for example, the image outside will be distorted.

 

Atoms are actually mostly space. If the nucleus is the size of a full stop, then the nearest electron would be 100 or so metres away. I think light photons are much smaller so can come through the atoms and space between atoms.

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: Glass, atoms, trasnparant.

top

posted on 2009-12-10 15:33:21 | Report abuse


Reply

Edward says:

Atoms are pretty much empty space. And their proximity does not decide whether or not a material is transparent. 

It is how the atoms or molecules are arranged that is important. 

In say Iron, the atoms are all jumbled up much so that when photons hit the iron, very few, if any make it to the other side.

In glass however, the atoms are arranged in a way that allows photons to pass through gaps. think of them all arranged in vertical lines, the photons have a clear way through the material. 

If you take a piece of glass and fold it or look through frosted glass, the surface is not smooth making the light scatter jumbling up the image.

It is true that glass is a slow moving liquid and the atoms are not truly stable, but the bumps in the bottom of churches and such are normally due to the methods of manufacture of glass from hundreds of years ago. It would take thousands of years at the speed glass is moving to achieve such bumps!

 

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: Glass, atoms, trasnparant.

top

posted on 2010-11-16 18:21:40 | Report abuse


Reply

Jon-Richfield says:

The previous answers were reasonable, but a lot of what happens at the atomic level is harder to put reasonably. Here are a few relevant points.  

First, forget the flowing of old glass. Viscous substances like toffee and tar can flow slowly, but the liquid in glass flows no faster than most crystals "creep". For all practical purposes it is solid. What makes it "liquid" is not that it flows (it doesn't) but that the molecules in the substance are jumbled. Neighbouring molecules are pretty well ordered, but they are jumbled enough that distant neighbours are not ordered relative to each other.  Anyone who has been caught in a crowd of people too crushed together to move will have the idea. You will seldom be face to face with anyone, but instead will stand at a reasonably comfortable orientation. You could however be at any orientation relative to someone a few bodies away. If you had been in a military platoon however, everyone would be standing facing the same way, no matter how far apart. That sort of lattice corresponds to a crystalline state.

The reason for the bumps and thicker lower ends of old panes is that that was as neatly as they could make glass by the early techniques of those days, and it was the most convenient orientation to install the panes.

Next. Remember that from this point of view, light is wearing its wave hat; it is not behaving much like particles. It is in effect an alternating electrical and magnetic vibration of a field. Squeezing between atoms, or between the components of atoms does not enter into the process. Even if it did, the wavelengths of visible light are hugely, thousands or millions of times greater than the components under discussion.

For light to get through glass is not like weevils squeezing between grain kernels, but rather like sound getting through glass; it doesn't squeeze through; it rides through in the interactions of the glass molecules.  

Because the light vibrations are changes in electromagnetic fields, they interact with any electric particles they meet on the way. If the particles could move in such a way as to be shaken by the light, then moving them would either absorb the light's energy, swallowing up the wave, so to speak, or send a copy of the wave back like an echo, reflecting the light. Those sorts of effects are what one might expect from electrical conductors like metals. Other sorts of conductors like salt solutions do pass visible light, but they are not transparent to various other wavelengths.  

Transparent glass however, does not have electric charges that move at the right frequency to interfere with the wavelengths of visible light, so the electromagnetic vibrations pass through without much interference of the type that we find in metals. (The interference of refraction etc is another matter.)  

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: Glass, atoms, trasnparant.

top

posted on 2010-11-16 19:23:49 | Report abuse

Reply

mattgrubb says:

so in a simplfied explnation if i understand correctly the wave as it is passing through a transparent material, does so because the wave of photons is not scattered by the molecules in the material. This is happening beacuse they are more orderly aligned within the transparent material. However when the light photon attempt passage through a non transparent material it is being scattered away from the material because the surface is non orderly pattern of atom.

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: Glass, atoms, trasnparant.

top

posted on 2010-12-25 04:19:43 | Report abuse


The last word is ...

the place where you ask questions about everyday science

Answer questions, vote for best answers, send your videos and audio questions, save favourite questions and answers, share with friends...

register now


ADVERTISMENT