Advanced search

Answers


Depending on which way up it is, a cocktail stick with a cherry and a slice of apple either floats or sinks. Why?

Having discovered the joys of the "appletini" (vodka mixed with apple juice, cider or apple liquor) I have a question.

The garnish is a slice of apple and a Maraschino or glacé cherry on a cocktail stick. If the cherry is at the bottom of the stick it floats in the appletini, but with the apple slice at the bottom it sinks. Why? Surely the buoyancy of the two items combined is an absolute and their orientation should make no difference.

I shall leave it to the imagination as to the amount of 'tinis consumed before this anomaly became a burning conversation topic!

Richard Batho, St Saviour, Jersey

Editorial status: In magazine.

sssss
 (no votes)

submit an answer
  • Member status
  • none

Categories: Domestic Science, Unanswered.

Tags: float, appletini, apple, cherry, cocktail, buoyancy.

 

Report abuse


3 answer(s)


Reply

thomasdickinson says:

Interesting question. The main reason would be that although together they may have the same buoyancy, but as the apple is more dense and displaces more water, it has enough weight to break the surface of the water and sinks. It takes the cherry with it because once it has broken the surface tension, it is easy for it to sink. This is like a helicopter. It can land easily, but to take off, it needs a lot more energy than it does to land. The apple also absorbs water while a glaced cherry does not. This increases the weight and drags it down further.

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: float, appletini, apple, cherry, cocktail, buoyancy.

top

posted on 2009-09-29 19:53:58 | Report abuse


Reply

Moderator says:

Ethanol acts as a wetting agent, so in an alcoholic drink the submerged slice of apple holds too little air to float the non-buoyant, sugary cherry. The assembly will thus sink, though if you add soda, enough bubbles might attach to the apple to make the whole thing float again.

Human sloshing complicates insights after the fourth glass of appletini, but buoyancy is a more complicated affair than density considerations might suggest. For example, a boat that is seaworthy might sink if capsized.

Try dropping a clean, dry pin or razor blade gently onto a glass of still, pure water. Dropped endwise the object sinks; the metal is too dense. But surface tension will support the item if you gently drop it flat onto the fluid, especially if the metal is lightly waxed or oiled.

The behaviour of your appletini garnish is similar in some ways. The waxy skin and the broad shape of an unpeeled slice of apple on the surface of the drink can resist both the wetting and the shipping of fluid over the edge of the slice.

The stimulation of considering this question's complications should mitigate the brain-addling aspects of appletini, though, sadly, not to the extent of fully reversing them.

Antony David, London, UK

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: float, appletini, apple, cherry, cocktail, buoyancy.

top

posted on 2010-06-16 12:49:06 | Report abuse


Reply

Moderator says:

Surface tension effects probably account for the observations. If the buoyancy of the cocktail stick assembly is nearly neutral, a flat slice of apple, when uppermost and level with the cocktail surface, may provide a sufficiently long perimeter for surface tension to hold the assembly up. The spherical cherry in the same position has little or no perimeter on which surface tension can act. The coating on the cherry may also reduce surface tension.

Try replacing the apple slice with a small ball of apple and see if the stick now sinks even with the apple uppermost. If this experiment fails, the cocktail may have aged, so drink it and try again with a new one...

Paul Gladwell, Northwich, Cheshire, UK

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: float, appletini, apple, cherry, cocktail, buoyancy.

top

posted on 2010-06-16 12:49:26 | Report abuse


The last word is ...

the place where you ask questions about everyday science

Answer questions, vote for best answers, send your videos and audio questions, save favourite questions and answers, share with friends...

register now


ADVERTISMENT