Advanced search

Answers



1 answer(s)


Reply

Jon-Richfield says:

You have happened on a typical example of the existentialist problem.  How do we know that anything is conscious in any defensible sense of the term? How do we know for example, that the caterpillar is conscious? All we really can tell is that its nervous system can receive certain stimuli and control its body in responding to them.

One practical point of view, and arguably the simplest, is to accept this as evidence for consciousness.

Now, if we do accept this as our criterion for consciousness, then certain kinds of pupa (the term "chrysalis" is not much used any more) that cannot move at all until the adult emerges, might not seem very conscious for all we can tell, but most kinds of pupa of Lepidopteran insects (butterflies and other moths) can in fact wriggle if disturbed.  How effective it is as a means of defence, I cannot say; all they can move is the abdomen, but I suppose if that is all you can do, it sometimes may be better than doing nothing.

What is pretty definite, is that they are as conscious as anyone could reasonably expect; they do not in general wriggle when they are not disturbed, and they do wriggle when they are disturbed. Although close inspection of a moth's pupa shows that within its outer shell its body is complete, the only part it can move is its abdomen, and that is the part that it does move. Certain kinds of pupa that shelter in tunnels or similar structures have spiky abdomens and about at the time that the moth emerges, they wriggle the abdomen in such a way as to move forward, ready to emerge.

Taken all together, that sounds about as much like consciousness as anything that it might make sense to demand in the circumstances.

sssss
 (no votes)

Tags: butterflies, chrysalis, caterpillar, metamorphosis.

top

posted on 2010-12-10 08:13:28 | Report abuse


The last word is ...

the place where you ask questions about everyday science

Answer questions, vote for best answers, send your videos and audio questions, save favourite questions and answers, share with friends...

register now


ADVERTISMENT